In the age of online reviews, Trustpilot has positioned itself as a beacon of transparency, a platform where real users share authentic experiences. However, the rosy facade starts to crumble when businesses find themselves entangled in the web of Trustpilot’s policies, questionable practices, and what some describe as outright extortion.
For many companies, the nightmare begins when a user, willingly or not, leaves a review on Trustpilot. Such was the case for Shoprocket in 2019 when a user posted a 5-star review, initiating the company’s involuntary inclusion on the platform. The seemingly benign act of user-generated content takes a dark turn when businesses realize they have no control over the reviews posted about them.
Trustpilot allows anyone to add a “business profile” to its platform. Once added, it becomes a permanent fixture, immune to removal. While a business can claim its profile by verifying legal representation, the ability to eliminate the company or its information from Trustpilot remains nonexistent. This lack of control becomes particularly problematic when the reviews are fake or when the relationship with Trustpilot turns sour, leading to false accusations of system abuse.
The paradoxical nature of Trustpilot’s terms compounds the issue. On one hand, the platform emphasizes the necessity of accepting its terms to use the service, whether free or paid. On the other hand, businesses claim they never consented to be listed on Trustpilot, a right seemingly revoked when a review was submitted without proper checks or verification.
To respond to a review on Trustpilot, businesses must register and, inevitably, accept the terms. This creates a “catch 22” situation where a business is compelled to agree to terms it never willingly accepted in the first place. Trustpilot’s insistence on these terms, regardless of consent, raises ethical concerns about the platform’s commitment to fairness and openness.
In a demonstration of the platform’s vulnerability, an experiment was conducted by posting a review for a fictitious company. The review, publicly available on Trustpilot, highlights the potential for abuse. If left unaddressed, this flaw allows anyone to tarnish a business’s reputation by posting false and damaging reviews that remain indefinitely.
The consequences become more severe when considering the impact on local businesses. An individual with malicious intent can easily post false reviews about a local business, and these reviews, once published on Trustpilot, become a permanent stain on the business’s online reputation. While Trustpilot offers the option for businesses to claim their profiles and request investigations into the legitimacy of reviews, the burden of proof often falls on the business, creating an uneven playing field.
Trustpilot’s promise of a free and open platform clashes with the reality faced by businesses caught in its web. The inability to control one’s presence on the platform, coupled with a coercive acceptance of terms, raises questions about the platform’s commitment to fairness and transparency. As businesses grapple with the repercussions of unwanted and potentially false reviews, Trustpilot must address these concerns to live up to its own ideals and rebuild trust within the business community
Leave a Reply